I had my doubts about the break in of band saw blades myself. I still might but they are less than what they used to be.
Most of the blade manufactures recommend blade break in. From what I read (I will have to look around to see if I can find it again) from one manufacture that kind of made sense to me is this:
Breaking in a blade tends to round over the tooth vs. breaking a tooth off. This is all on a very small scale of course. When applying half pressure or feed rate, what ever that means when hand cutting on a typical 4x6 saw, for at least the first ten minutes, your break in cutting action doesn't rip up larger chunks (again, very small scale here) but tends to round off the cutting edge to better handle a full load (again, what ever that is) after ten minutes.
I can't prove what this blade manufacture said (it was either Lenox or Olson) but their argument makes some sense to me. Generally, I make it a point to be easy on a new blade, at least for the first few minutes of use, and then return to pushing it as hard as I can because I have no patience for cutting stuff on a band saw. Your mileage may vary and it may be silly to even think of breaking in a blade.