I think its a matter of finding a suitable material, thats readily/locally available for a lot of folks. Personally, I've never come across a piece of granite that I felt would work, or I would have tried it. I've scoured the local hardware and tile stores, and am yet to find a piece of tile that I thought would work as well as the ceramic glass. I'm with Laurence..... if it works, then its "right".
Personally, I'm lucky that my mom does stained glass work...and has a glass grinder!

For the way I grind, I want the leading/trailing edges of the platen just a fraction outward, to the point that if I'm working with something longer then the platen, the work piece doesn't get "gouged" by the top or bottom contact wheel. That certainly doesn't make any other method "wrong"....again, its what's best suited to each individual.
The local outfit I purchase my ceramic glass platen liners from will bevel or radius the edges if requested, but after having them do it once, and not liking the results, I just go to my Mom's place and use her glass grinder.